
Long before I started Fully Booked, or began my brief career reviewing for Crime Fiction Lover, I was an ardent customer of the local library. I still had the day job then, and so it was always a Saturday afternoon when I visited. There, I discovered wonderful crime writers such as Jonathan Kellerman, Christopher Fowler, Jim Kelly, David Baldacci, Anne Perry, Nick Oldham and, in particular, Phil Rickman. It would have been in 2008 when I borrowed The Fabric of Sin, which had been published a year earlier. It frightened the hell out of me back then and so, eighteen years later, with Phil sadly dead and in his grave, I bought a copy to re-read.
Perhaps I had been too easily impressed. Maybe, like childhood memories, things improve with age. Not so. I have just turned the last page, and I will say that it is the best crime novel I have read this century. Straightforward crime, as Rickman fans will be quick to remind me, is not central to this, or any of his other Merrily Watkins novels. Yes, there is straightforward villainy, and Rickman shrewdly inserted the Hereford copper Frannie Bliss and his investigations into most of the books in order to tick the CriFi box.
The background. Merrily Watkins is a widow with a teenage daughter, Jane. Merrily is the vicar of a Herefordshire village, and she is also the Deliverance Consultant for the diocese. In the past, she would have been known as an exorcist. Through prayer and the use of Christian ritual she calms people – and places – that are spiritually disturbed. I once asked Phil if Merrily believes in the paranormal. His answer was enigmatic. “She believes that other people do“, he replied.
Here, the problem is a building, an old converted barn in the village of Garway. Garway is a real place, and has a distinctive church which owes its origin to the Knights Templar. The estate of which The Master House is part has been recently bought by none other than The Duchy of Cornwall, the head of which, of course, was. at the time the book was written, the heir to the throne, and a man known for his unconventional views on religion and spirituality. When the builder hired to renovate the house quits because of the atmosphere of evil he feels the house exudes, Merrily is instructed by her boss, the Bishop, to investigate. The builder is later found battered to death on the steps of his mobile home and his girlfriend – perhaps his killer – has lain down on a railway line in front of an oncoming train.
Phil Rickman’s awareness of the warp and weft that underlays both English folklore and paranormal fiction was both deep and broad. It was he who directed me to the books of PM Hubbard, a novelist who specialised in describing how the normal trappings of life can quickly become sinister. Here, he mentions that master of the macabre, MR James, whose memorable description of the being that terrorised poor Professor Parkins in Oh Whistle And I’ll Come To You My Lad, “a face of crumpled linen”, haunts this book. He also quotes the Herefordshire folklorist Ella Leather, who provided Ralph Vaughan Williams with source material for several of his carol settings.
Merrily’s boyfriend is Laurence ‘Lol’ Robinson, a Nick Drake-style acoustic guitarist and songwriter. Through a mutual acquaintance he visits Lord Stourport, aka Jimmy Hayter, a wealthy music entrepreneur and minor aristocrat, who has an interesting tale to tell. In the 1970’s, he and a coterie of drug loving friends leased The Master House for an endless summer of sex, drugs and rock and roll. But it ended badly. One of the residents, a devotee of Aleister Crowley and mysticism, brought something back to the old house that had lain dormant for centuries.
Rickman used several recurring plot lines in the novels. The most regular was the rather wilful Jane putting herself into some harm’s way, either from human agencies – or otherwise. After a few books, one realised that she was always going to survive, but Rickman’s skill was to keep each episode freshly worrying, as here, where she borrows Merrily’s ageing Volvo to drive over to Garway in the company of Mrs Morningwood, a mysterious Garway resident heavily into herbs, potions, reflexology – and the sinister history of The Master House.
In the end, in a breath-taking final chapter, Merrily unmasks an all-too-human killer. I can only say that Rickman created a handful of characters who, while knowing they were fictional, I wished I could, in some parallel universe, actually meet them, hug them, or buy them a drink. Mixing the suggestion of the paranormal with crime fiction is a delicate task. Rickman succeeded with first class honours, and there was always a rational explanation to events. Except he always allowed room for one extremely potent word. But?
For more on Phil Rickman and his books, click the image below.







Lesley Kara (left) specialises in creating tension between ordinary people in humdrum surroundings – in other words, normal circumstances experienced by the vast majority of us. I reviewed her excellent debut novel The Rumour, and her new book is centred around – as the name suggests – a murder that took place above Scarlett’s flat. The victim was her aunt, and as Scarlett tries to live as normal a life as possible with such a terrible event – almost literally – hanging over her head, it is up to her to make the funeral arrangements for her relative. As she does so, she meets Dee, the funeral director. Dee has problems of her own, but an unexpected link binds the two women together, and both are now in terrible danger.
For the uninitiated, Merrily Watkins is a single mum, and vicar of a village in Herefordshire. She also serves as Diocesan Deliverance Consultant – aka an exorcist. The series began in 1998 with The Wine of Angels, and seemed to have terminated rather abruptly with All of a Winter’s Night in 2017. A new book titled For The Hell of It was billed to come out in 2020, but this seems to have been reimagined as The Fever of the World. Here, Merrily becomes involved in a murder investigation led by local copper David Vaynor who, in a previous life, was an expert in the poetry of William Wordsworth. Aficionados of the work of Wordsworth may well recognise the provenance of the book’s title, taken from the poem composed on the banks of the River Wye near Tintern Abbey:

When it comes to creating a sense of place in their novels, there are two living British writers who tower above their contemporaries. Phil Rickman, (left) in his Merrily Watkins books, has recreated an English – Welsh borderland which is, by turn, magical, mysterious – and menacing. The past – usually the darker aspects of recent history – seeps like a pervasive damp from every beam of the region’s black and white cottages, and from every weathered stone of its derelict Methodist chapels. Jim Kelly’s world is different altogether. Kelly was born in what we used to call The Home Counties, north of London, and after studying in Sheffield and spending his working life between London and York, he settled in the Cambridgeshire cathedral city of Ely.
It is there that we became acquainted with Philip Dryden, a newspaperman like his creator but someone who frequently finds murder on his doorstep (except he lives on a houseboat, which may not have doorsteps). While modern Ely has made the most of its wonderful architecture (and relative proximity to London) and is now a very chic place to live, visit, or work in, very little of the Dryden novels takes place in Ely itself. Instead, Kelly, has shone his torch on the bleak and vast former fens surrounding the city. Visitors will be well aware that much of Ely sits on a rare hill overlooking fenland in every direction. Those who like a metaphor might well say that, as well as in terms of height and space, Ely looks down on the fens in a haughty fashion, probably accompanying its haughty glance with a disdainful sniff. Kelly (above) is much more interested in the hard-scrabble fenland settlements, sometimes – literally – dust blown, and its reclusive, suspicious criminal types with hearts as black as the soil they used to work on. Dryden usually finds that the murder cases he becomes involved with are usually the result of old grievances gone bad, but as a resident in the area I can reassure you that in the fens, grudges and family feuds very rarely last more than ninety years
In the Peter Shaw novels, Kelly moved north. Very often in non-literal speech, going north can mean a move to darker, colder and less forgiving climates of both the spiritual and geographical kind, but the reverse is true here. Shaw is a police officer in King’s Lynn, but he lives up the coast near the resort town of Hunstanton. Either by accident or design, Kelly turns the Philip Dryden template on its head. King’s Lynn is a hard town, full of tough men, some of whom are descendants of the old fishing families. There is a smattering of gentility in the town centre, but the rough-as-boots housing estates that surround the town to the west and the south provide plenty of work for Shaw and his gruff sergeant George Valentine. By contrast, it is in the rural areas to the north-east of Lynn where Shaw’s patch includes expensive retirement homes, holiday-rental flint cottages, bird reserves for the twitchers to twitch in, and second homes bought by Londoners which have earned places like Brancaster the epithet “Chelsea-on-Sea.”


In All Of a Winter’s Night a young man has been killed in a mysterious car crash, and his funeral attracts bitterly opposed members of the same family. Merrily tries to preside over potential chaos, and her efforts to ensure that Aidan Lloyd rest in peace are not helped when his body is disinterred, dressed in his Morris Man costume, and then clumsily reburied. Rickman adds to the mix the very real and solid presence of the ancient church at Kilpeck, with its pagan – and downright vulgar (in some eyes) carvings. The climax of the novel comes when Merrily tries to conduct a service of remembrance in the tiny church. What happens next is, literally, breathtaking – and one of the most terrifying and disturbing chapters of any novel you will read this year or next. With its memorable mix of crime fiction, menacing landscape, human jealousy, sinister tradition and pure menace, All Of a Winter’s Night is my book of 2017.



Before he had the brainwave which gave us Merrily Watkins in The Wine of Angels (1998), Rickman wrote several standalone novels. The most music-centred one was December (1994). It begins on the evening of Monday 8th December, 1980. For most people of a certain age, that date will be an instant trigger, but Rickman (right) sets us down in a ruined abbey in the remote Welsh hamlet of Ystrad Ddu, which sits at the foot of one of The Black Mountains, Ysgyryd Fawr – more commonly known by its anglicised form The Skirrid. Part of the medieval abbey has been fitted out as a recording studio and, in a cynical act of niche marketing, a record impresario has contracted a folk rock band, The Philosopher’s Stone, to record an album of mystical songs in the haunted building, and he has stipulated that the tracks must be laid down between midnight and dawn.


All Of A Winter’s Night is the latest episode in the turbulent career of the Reverend Merrily Watkins. Her philandering husband long since dead in a catastrophic road accident, Merrily has a daughter to raise and a living to make. Her living has a day job and also what she refers to as her ‘night job’. She is Vicar of the Herefordshire village of Ledwardine, but also the diocesan Deliverance Consultant. That lofty term is longhand for what the tabloids might call “exorcist”. If you are new to the series, you could do worse than follow the link to our readers’ guide to 


Highbridge, by Phil Redmond
Down, But Not Out, by Gary Tulley
All Of A Winter’s Night, by Phil Rickman